The Chest of Legends is the rarest and hardest to obtain chest in Sea of Thieves, it is obtained by completing Legendary voyages.

This chest grants reputations for Athena's Fortune to those who cash it in. This chest is cashed in to the Mysterious Stranger in the Tavern at any outpost. Just like most chests, the Chest of Legends can also be found in the ashen form, increasing the experience and gold gained from selling it.

Normal and ashen voyages for this chest are obtained at the Pirate Legend Hideout from the Pirate Lord.